Is Pomade or Clay Better for Styling Men’s Hair? Our Advice & Recommendations (2024)

Table of contents

Pomade vs Clay: A Quick Rundown of the Differences What is Hair Clay? What is Natural Hair Clay? What Hairstyles is Men’s Hair Clay Good For? Messy Quiff Faux Hawk Side Part Slick Back Does Hair Clay Work With Every Men's Hair Type? What is Hair Pomade? Which is Better: Pomade or Clay? FAQs

Wondering if pomade or clay is better for your daily styling routine? We’ve compared both of these hair styling classics to determine which will help you achieve your ideal ‘do.

Both hair pomade and clay are popular choices for men’s hair styling, and that’s because they’re both good in their own right. They do have their differences, though, such as the consistency of the product itself and how it performs.

You might find one or the other (or even a combination of both) the best for your hair, depending on what style you’re looking to achieve.

So let’s break down the basics of pomade and clayso you can make an informed decision about which one is better for styling your hair.

Pomade vs Clay: A Quick Rundown of the Differences

With the number of products in the hair styling market (spray wax and texture powder? Luckily, we prefer to keep our products simple), it's difficult to get a good grasp of what each product actually is and what it's used for.

It's also difficult when each brand has different ingredients, so you really don't know which way is up.

To make it simple, we've outlined the key differences below…

Hair Clay

Pomade

  • Thick and creamy
  • Add texture and volume without added shine (matte finish)
  • Versatile
  • Medium to maximum hold
  • No damaging synthetics (talking about our Compound Clay here, we can't speak for others)
  • Thick and creamy or gel-like
  • Wet-look
  • Strong hold
  • Difficult to wash out
  • Typically petroleum-based

Is Pomade or Clay Better for Styling Men’s Hair? Our Advice & Recommendations (5)

What is Hair Clay?

Hair clay is a popular choice of hair styling product with a thick and creamy consistency. It's typically used to create volume, add texture, and hold your hairstyle in place.

When you use hair clay, there is no added shine, leaving you with a natural, matte finish – perfect for those with greasy or fine hair.

To apply hair clay, you would warm a small pea-sized amount in your hands (you can add more later, but it's best to start off small so you can build it up). You'd then work it through your hair from root to tip, styling and manipulating the hair as you go.

The versatility of the product means you can apply it to dry or damp hair.

Like most hair products,you’ve got to watch the label. Hair clays can contain unnatural ingredients like phthalates, sulphates, and silicones, which are damaging to hair. Best to steer clear of these.

What is Natural Hair Clay?

Natural hair clay is exactly that. It’s formulated using natural ingredients rather than harsh, synthetic chemicals. It’ll contain natural clay, commonly Bentonite or Kaolin, as well as other hair-nourishing ingredients, like vitamins and minerals.

You’ll still get the great styling effects, but only using ingredients that are kind to the hair.

Our Compound Clay is a prime example of a natural hair clay. Its unique formula is perfect for those who require sleek styles with maximum hold. Let's pay special attention to our ingredients.

  • Icelandic Bentonite Clay: Formed from rare volcanic ash, bentonite clay spreads easily through the hair, adding thickness and texture as it sets. The heaviness of the product is counteracted with kaolinite for a perfectly balanced product.
  • French Kaolinite Clay: Renowned for its detoxifying properties, kaolinite softens and smooths the hair whilst adding texture and volume. It's light, so when mixed with bentonite, it forms the ideal consistency for all hair types.
  • Hydrogenated Organic Mexican Jojoba Oil: Rich in vitamins, minerals, and natural antioxidants, jojoba oil is non-greasy but deeply hydrating. It will keep your scalp in the best condition possible to improve hair growth.
  • Organic Arabian Aloe Vera: Working to repair dead skin cells and condition the hair, aloe vera is a fantastic addition to hair clay.

Is Pomade or Clay Better for Styling Men’s Hair? Our Advice & Recommendations (7)

What Hairstyles is Men’s Hair Clay Good For?

Men's hair clay can be used for lots of styles, the list is pretty endless. But hairstyles that work particularly well with hair clay are those that need controlling. And a lot of controlling at that.

That doesn’t mean to say you can’t use hair clay if you have less hair, on the contrary, you can use it to build volume and texture and support healthy hair growth.

Here are some hairstyles you can try using hair clay:

Messy Quiff

Step 1) Add a small amount of hair clay into your palms and rub together to warm. This’ll make it more workable.

Step 2) Make sure your hair is slightly damp (this helps increase the hold and enhance the messy look) and begin raking the product through your hair.

Step 3) Ensure all strands are getting covered as you rake and manipulate the hair upwards without being too uniform with it.

Step 4) Once you’ve got the desired look, blow dry to maintain maximum volume and hold.

How to Achieve a Messy Look Without Scruffiness

Faux Hawk

Is Pomade or Clay Better for Styling Men’s Hair? Our Advice & Recommendations (9)

Step 1) Take a small amount of product and work into your hands to warm.

Step 2) You want your hair slightly drier for this one, so leave time to air dry or blow dry if necessary.

Step 3) The faux hawk is quick and messy, so you don’t need a lot of pruning. Simply work the product into your hair, pushing it up as you go.

Tip: You don’t want to push it up too much or use too much product because you’ll end up with a full-blown mohawk with spikes. Not ideal.

Side Part Slick Back

Step 1) Warm some hair clay in your hands. It’s buildable, so start small, and if you need more, you can add it.

Step 2) For this hairstyle, your hair can be slightly damp or dry; it’s what suits you best. Work the product through your hair.

Step 3) Choose where you want your part to be, and run your finger through front to back to create a solid line.

Step 4) Once you’re happy with the position, begin dragging the clay down the side you’d like down, and rake the product through the side you’d like slicked back.

Step 5) When your hair looks like you envisioned it, blow dry it all in place for that extra hold.

Does Hair Clay Work With Every Men's Hair Type?

Hair clay is a fantastic addition to every man’s product collection. It’s so versatile that it can be used for many different hairstyles and every single hair type.

Looking after your scalp, whilst creating voluminous hairstyles isn’t just relevant to one hair type, which is why Compound Clay is created with everyone in mind. It’s ideal for mid-short-length hair, but we recommend it for all hair types.

What is Hair Pomade?

Pomade is another popular choice in men's hair styling. Due to its shiny formula, it is often used for hairstyles that require a wet, sleek look, like classic pompadours or mid-length waves.

Want to Know How to Get the Wet Look? Read Our Guide

There are two main types of pomades:oil-based and water-based.

Oil-based pomades have a thick, creamy/waxy consistency, providing a medium-strong hold. It's difficult to remove from the hair, so if you use this type of pomade, you'll need a clarifying shampoo to remove dirt and impurities before they have a chance to linger on your scalp.

Water-based pomades have a gel-like consistency and are much easier to remove from hair. They offer a stronghold without hair looking stiff, and some even condition the scalp.

The main ingredients you need to watch out for when buying pomades are:

Modern pomades are activated by water, so before application, you'll need to dampen your hair by spraying it or running it under the shower and letting it air/towel dry for a few minutes.

Once you've done this, you can warm the product in your hands, apply it to your hair starting from the thickest point, and style how you wish.

When the pomade is in,people often blow-dry their hair to help it set in place for a stronger hold.

Is Pomade or Clay Better for Styling Men’s Hair? Our Advice & Recommendations (16)

What Hairstyles & Hair Types Is Men’s Pomade Good For?

Pomade could be quite useful in a few hairstyles and types, and we’ll give you a few ideas below.


  • Fringe taper cut
  • Slick-back mid-length
  • Slick back ponytail
  • Curly quiff

Of course, you can replace the use of pomade with Compound Clay for any of these hairstyles.

Due to the heavy formula and wet look that comes from most pomades, they’re probably best used on thick or curly hair.

If it’s used on fine hair, it could weigh it down, making it look more sparse and greasy.

Find Out Your Hair Type With Our Helpful Article

Which is Better: Pomade or Clay?

Unfortunately, hairstyling isn't always black and white, so you'll need to do a little trial and error to find out what works best for your hair. But, as you've now heard, there are many benefits of opting for our Compound Clay over pomade.

That's not to say you can't use pomades, but there's a time and place.

To put it plainly, pinning clay and pomade together probably isn't fair game (especially when our Compound Clay is in the mix). They both offer different styles for different hair types, so it's impossible to say which one's'better'.

Salt Grooming only offers natural, premium products designed to improve your hair, not damage it.

You can shop our entire collection below and transform your hair styling game today.

FAQs

Which is Better: Wax, Clay or Pomade?

Personally, we always use a natural wax or natural clay for styling, or – better yet – a clay-wax hybrid compound.

You get much better results and reworkability with a clay-wax product than pomade. Plus, the natural ingredients in these formulas help to nourish and care for your hair while it styles.

Pomades, on the other hand, often contain harsh chemicals and can leave a greasy buildup on your scalp, although they do have their place for certain/particular styles.

Is Styling Clay Healthy for Hair?

Depending on the ingredients, hair clay is and is not healthy for your hair. With each brand claiming to be the best, you have to check what's in the product you're buying.

Ingredients to steer clear from include phthalates, parabens, and silicones.

Ingredients that are safe and beneficial include bentonite, kaolinite, and aloe vera. (All of which you can find in our Compound Clay)

What Hair Type is Clay Best For?

Our Compound Clay works on all hair types, but we recommend it most to people with medium to short hair lengths.

Its lightweight, thickening formula with added scalp health ingredients means all hair types can enjoy the benefits.

Is It Okay to Use Clay or Pomade Every Day?

Using a clay or pomade every day is okay, so long as you’re using a sound, high-quality product. You should also apply a little to start and build it up, rather than going it with a lot.

You should also wash your hair 2 to 3 times a week to cleanse your hair of any product residue so it doesn't build up on your scalp.

Is Pomade or Clay Better for Styling Men’s Hair? Our Advice & Recommendations (21)

Piers Le Moignan

Piers Le Moignan is the founder and CEO of Salt Grooming, an award-winning British luxury men’s haircare and styling brand.

Founded in 2018, Piers has quickly grown the company into a global brand that has distributed to 43 countries and counting.

Headquartered in London, Piers leads an agile workforce of 10 employees and consultants, including the company’s formulation team which features some of the UK’s leading cosmetic scientists. Piers is responsible for overseeing logistics, supply chain, and performance marketing, and is the driving force behind Salt’s product innovation and brand/creative direction.

Previous to foundership, Piers spent a decade at some of London’s leading creative agencies, developing global brands and communications for the likes of Adidas, Jaguar Land Rover, British Airways, and more.

Read more

Salt Grooming Recomends

Is Pomade or Clay Better for Styling Men’s Hair? Our Advice & Recommendations (2024)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Recommended Articles
Article information

Author: Geoffrey Lueilwitz

Last Updated:

Views: 6222

Rating: 5 / 5 (80 voted)

Reviews: 87% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Geoffrey Lueilwitz

Birthday: 1997-03-23

Address: 74183 Thomas Course, Port Micheal, OK 55446-1529

Phone: +13408645881558

Job: Global Representative

Hobby: Sailing, Vehicle restoration, Rowing, Ghost hunting, Scrapbooking, Rugby, Board sports

Introduction: My name is Geoffrey Lueilwitz, I am a zealous, encouraging, sparkling, enchanting, graceful, faithful, nice person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.